Hidden Gems: Your Ultimate Guide to Handmade Jewelry in Ann Arbor

Ann Arbor is a city that never fails to surprise. Beyond its vibrant culture, historic streets, and inviting cafes, it is home to a remarkable handmade jewelry scene. Whether you’re searching for a one-of-a-kind gift or treating yourself to something special, the city’s local jewelry artisans have much to offer. Each shop and market holds a unique charm, making the search for the perfect piece an adventure in itself. This guide highlights the best spots for discovering handmade treasures, from tucked-away boutiques to bustling artisan markets.

Where to Buy Handmade Jewelry in Ann Arbor

Ann Arbor’s Must-Visit Jewelry Havens

Abracadabra Jewelry/Gem Gallery is a family-owned jewelry business founded at the 1973 Ann Arbor Art Fair. This full-service jeweler specializes in on-site custom jewelry design, production, repair, and appraisal. Their collection features pieces crafted by local artists, national designers, and fair-trade international artisans, with a focus on using recycled eco-metals, conflict-free diamonds, and ethically sourced gemstones.

Abracadabra offers unique and customizable designs inspired by nature, history, and cultural symbols, creating heirloom pieces that celebrate personal stories. They also incorporate rare and unconventional materials, such as Petoskey stones and Fordite, adding a Michigan touch to their jewelry. Beyond craftsmanship, Abracadabra is deeply committed to community engagement, supporting local organizations like Theatre Nova and the Michigan Theater, making it more than a jewelry store—it’s a vital part of Ann Arbor’s creative and cultural fabric.

2. 16 Hands: A Showcase of Artistic Passion

Nestled on Main Street, 16 Hands is a hidden treasure that feels like stepping into a curated artisan marketplace. The jewelry collection here showcases the work of talented local artists, each piece reflecting a blend of creativity and craftsmanship. 

The owner has a knack for selecting truly unique items, making this store a standout. My mixed-metal earrings from 16 Hands always draw compliments, and it’s no wonder—each creation tells a story that’s hard to find elsewhere. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make browsing a pleasure, so take your time exploring all that this shop has to offer.

Where to Buy Handmade Jewelry in Ann Arbor

3. Schlanderer & Sons Jewelry

Schlanderer & Sons Jewelry has been a cornerstone of Ann Arbor’s jewelry scene since 1933, offering fine jewelry, designer watches, custom creations, and expert repairs. A fifth-generation, family-owned business, it’s known for its dedication to craftsmanship and customer relationships. Their collection includes pieces from some of the world’s best designers and suppliers, blending timeless beauty with modern elegance.

In addition to their stunning jewelry selection, Schlanderer & Sons carries high-end watches, featuring brands like Tissot and Belair. Their custom jewelry design team works closely with clients to craft unique, meaningful pieces, and their repair services are trusted for preserving cherished heirlooms. Beyond jewelry, they offer elegant gifts, from silver platters to picture frames, making it a destination for special occasions.

Where to Buy Handmade Jewelry in Ann Arbor

4. Rock Paper Scissors: A Gift Shop with a Twist

Although Rock Paper Scissors is widely known for its cards and quirky gifts, its jewelry collection deserves just as much attention. The shop features pieces from Michigan-based artists, emphasizing locally made, high-quality designs. Their price points are accessible, making it easy to find a thoughtful gift or an addition to your own collection without overspending. 

This is the perfect spot for picking up something both beautiful and meaningful. If you’re unsure about what to choose, the helpful staff is always ready to make recommendations tailored to your needs.

5. Lewis Jewelers

Lewis Jewelers has been a trusted name in Ann Arbor’s jewelry scene since 1921, with their exceptional line-up of fine jewelry and watches. Committed to quality and integrity, they provide expert guidance with a non-commissioned team for a no-pressure experience. From engagement rings to watch repairs, their service is thorough, friendly, and reliable, earning them loyal customers for decades.

Beyond jewelry, Lewis Jewelers plays an active role in the community. They support local fundraisers and events, including contributions to the University of Michigan C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital, Meals on Wheels, and Alzheimer’s walks. Located within Ann Arbor’s city limits, Lewis Jewelers blends timeless craftsmanship with a deep commitment to the community.

Found Gallery is a visual delight and a haven for jewelry enthusiasts. The shop is beautifully curated, with a jewelry collection that stands out for its originality. Each piece feels like a miniature work of art, crafted by skilled artisans who take pride in their work. 

Found Gallery frequently introduces new artists and designs, so every visit offers fresh discoveries. It’s hard to leave without wanting to add something special to your collection. The gallery also provides a relaxing shopping experience, making it easy to lose track of time while browsing.

7. Ann Arbor Art Center: Supporting Local Creativity

The Ann Arbor Art Center’s gallery shop is a lesser-known gem with a fantastic jewelry selection. Rotating exhibits highlight different local artists throughout the year, ensuring a diverse and ever-changing inventory. 

Where to Buy Handmade Jewelry in Ann Arbor

Shopping here not only provides access to unique, handcrafted pieces but also supports Ann Arbor’s thriving art community. It’s a win-win for anyone who values originality and giving back to local creators. Be sure to visit during special exhibitions, as they often feature exclusive designs that capture the essence of the city’s artistic spirit.

Pop-Ups and Markets: The Heart of the Local Scene

Ann Arbor’s artisan markets and pop-up events are vibrant hubs for discovering handmade jewelry. These events bring together local creators, offering a wide variety of styles and designs. Some standout events include:

  • The Sunday Artisan Market in Kerrytown (April through December), which features a rotating roster of artists and creators.
  • The Ann Arbor Art Fair is an annual event where you’ll find exceptional handmade pieces alongside other artistic treasures. Arrive early for the best selection.
  • First Fridays in Downtown Ann Arbor, where galleries host special jewelry trunk shows that showcase the latest designs.
  • Holiday Markets at Kerrytown Concert House, where local artisans unveil their seasonal collections.

Where to Buy Handmade Jewelry in Ann Arbor

These gatherings offer not only a chance to shop but also an opportunity to connect with the artists and learn about their creative processes. Many artisans are happy to share stories about their inspiration and craftsmanship, making these events a memorable experience.

Tips for Building Your Collection

After years of exploring Ann Arbor’s handmade jewelry scene, I’ve picked up a few tips for making the most of it:

  • Sign up for shop newsletters. Many stores and artists host events or release special collections that are only advertised through email.
  • Follow artists on social media. Local creators often share new designs and small-batch releases that sell out quickly.
  • Ask about custom work. Many artisans are open to creating personalized pieces tailored to your style and preferences.
  • Visit the University of Michigan’s School of Art & Design sales. These events are great for discovering emerging talent.
  • Check out seasonal events. Many shops and galleries host exclusive sales during the holidays or summer months.

Why Handmade Jewelry Matters

Choosing handmade jewelry goes beyond simply buying an accessory. It’s about investing in something personal and meaningful. Every piece has a story—of the artist who created it, the inspiration behind the design, and the community that supports it. Wearing handmade jewelry is like carrying a piece of Ann Arbor with you wherever you go.

Moreover, supporting local artists contributes to the preservation and growth of the city’s creative community. Each purchase helps sustain the artisans who pour their heart and soul into their work, ensuring that this vibrant tradition continues to thrive. By choosing handmade, you’re also making a sustainable choice, as these pieces are often crafted with care and attention to the environment.

Final Thoughts

Ann Arbor’s handmade jewelry is truly something special. Whether you’re a long-time resident or just visiting, exploring these shops and markets is a rewarding experience. You’ll not only find beautiful pieces to cherish but also gain a deeper appreciation for the talent and creativity that define this city. So whether you’re a longtime local or just visiting our wonderful city, take some time to explore these amazing shops. And when you find that perfect piece (or pieces – who’s counting?), remember: supporting local artists is always in style!

Get the best of Ann Arbor—events, tips, and updates—straight to your inbox!


Table of Contents

Questions?

Guidelines & Tips
Image Clarity

Logos should be no smaller than 160 x 160 px, with the subject matter centered as possible to avoid being cut off at the edges.

Image Size Limits

Images can have a maximum file size of 1 MB. Should you need to compress your images, no problem! Here’s a free tool with super simple instructions.

  1. Open Squoosh.
  2. Upload an image.
  3. Choose WebP from the dropdown.
  4. Download your optimized image.
Guidelines & Tips
Image Clarity

Headshot (Listing Preview) images should be no smaller than 800 x 900 px and Headshot (Listing Page) images should be no smaller than 160 x 160 px, with the subject matter centered as possible to avoid being cut off at the edges.

Image Size Limits

Images can have a maximum file size of 1 MB. Should you need to compress your images, no problem! Here’s a free tool with super simple instructions.

  1. Open Squoosh.
  2. Upload an image.
  3. Choose WebP from the dropdown.
  4. Download your optimized image.
Google Reviews
Display your reviews with these simple steps.
  1. From your EmbedSocial dashboard, click the ‘+’ icon next to the ‘Sources’ menu item.
  2. Choose ‘Google.’
  3. Click ‘Connect Google Account.’
  4. Authenticate with Google using the credentials tied to the account where your Google Reviews are coming from.
  5. After authentication is successful, click ‘Create Widget.’
  6. Copy the unique identifier from the Widget Code, as shown in the image below, highlighted in blue.
  7. Edit your Listing and paste the code into the ‘Google Reviews’ field.
  8. Save changes.
Guidelines & Tips
Image Clarity

Cover and Gallery images should be no smaller than 1920 x 1080 px for the best clarity, and the subject matter should be as centered as possible to avoid being cut off at the edges.

Image Size Limits

Images can have a maximum file size of 1 MB. Should you need to compress your images, no problem! Here’s a free tool with super simple instructions.

  1. Open Squoosh.
  2. Upload an image.
  3. Choose WebP from the dropdown.
  4. Download your optimized image.
Add Listing

Wondering if you already have a Listing on our platform? Click here to find out.

Claim Listing

Find and take control of any Listings you have on our platform. No Listing to Claim? Click here to add one.