Pizza lovers, unite! After countless taste tests and late-night slices in Ann Arbor, we’ve compiled the ultimate guide to the best pizza spots in town. Whether you’re a local, a student, or just passing through, these pizzerias are worth the stop – and may even change the way you think about pizza!
These Pizza Spots Will Take Your Tastebuds to New Heights
1. NYPD (New York Pizza Depot) – State Street
If you’re looking for classic New York-style pizza, NYPD is a must. Known for its generous slices and late hours, this spot has been a lifesaver for many students burning the midnight oil. Their pepperoni slice has the perfect cheese pull, and their garlic knots? Pure bliss in bread form. Pro tip: arrive early at lunch for the freshest slices, and don’t skip the ranch dressing (you’ll thank us later). Their buffalo chicken pizza is another winner, with just the right mix of creamy and spicy flavors.
2. Mani Osteria – Liberty Street
Mani Osteria’s wood-fired pizzas are a game-changer. Known for creative ingredients and authentic Italian flavors, this spot is a treat for pizza lovers who enjoy something a little different. Try the Tartufo pizza with black truffle and egg – it’s a fan favorite. And if you’re visiting with family or on a date, the experience is worth the slightly higher price. Don’t miss their seasonal mushroom pizza, and if you can, ask for a side of their homemade chili oil for an extra kick!
3. Cottage Inn – East William Street
Cottage Inn is a classic, serving Ann Arbor since 1948. Their deep-dish pizza has a loyal following, and their Greek pizza is legendary. They were the first to deliver pizza in Ann Arbor, and they’ve built a name for consistently delicious pies. If you’re extra hungry, go for the Cottage Special, loaded with enough toppings to satisfy any craving. Fun fact: their pans have been seasoning pizzas for decades, adding an unbeatable depth of flavor.
4. Pizza House – Church Street
When it’s 3 AM, and only pizza will do, Pizza House is the place to be. Their Chicago-style stuffed pizza is a local legend – think of it as a thick, cheesy slice of heaven. Portions here are huge, so come hungry or share with friends. Start with their pizza dough chips and spinach dip, then dive into a slice of their BBQ chicken or Chicago-style pizza. And yes, their ranch dressing is as addictive as you’ve heard.
5. Bigalora – North University
For fans of wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pizzas, Bigalora is a must-visit. The crust has a perfect char, and the flavors are carefully crafted, from the Bee Sting pizza (with honey and spicy salami) to seasonal creations like asparagus and prosciutto. Bigalora ferments its dough for 72 hours to achieve a unique flavor, so every bite is unforgettable. Bonus: they offer excellent happy hour deals, making it a great spot for a casual evening.
6. Anthony’s Gourmet Pizza – Packard Street
Anthony’s may be one of Ann Arbor’s best-kept pizza secrets. Their thin crust is perfectly crispy, and they don’t skimp on the toppings. The BBQ chicken pizza is a crowd-pleaser, but their homemade Italian sausage is what really sets them apart – they make it in-house using a family recipe. The friendly staff is just icing on the cake (or cheese on the pizza).
7. Jolly Pumpkin – Main Street
Yes, Jolly Pumpkin is primarily a brewery, but its pizza deserves its own spotlight. Known for unique, farm-to-table ingredients and a flavorful sourdough crust, this spot is ideal for adventurous eaters. Pair their mushroom and goat cheese pizza with a glass of sour beer for a true Ann Arbor experience. And if you’re craving something extra, their truffle fries are hard to resist.
8. The Original Cottage Inn Restaurant – East William Street
The Original Cottage Inn location is a piece of Ann Arbor history. Located in a building with beautiful stained glass windows, this spot serves up unforgettable pizzas like the Mediterranean with feta and olives. With a cozy atmosphere and rich history, it’s a great spot to enjoy a slice (or several). Try the lunch buffet if you’re looking for all-you-can-eat pizza at a wallet-friendly price.
Tips for Enjoying Ann Arbor’s Pizza Scene
- Best times to visit: Weekend afternoons are ideal for avoiding crowds.
- Student discounts: Many spots offer discounts with a student ID.
- Online ordering: Perfect for Michigan’s chilly winters.
- Lunch specials: Great pizza, even better prices.
- Gluten-free and vegan options: Many places now offer dietary-friendly choices that are still delicious.
- Late-night hours: Hours vary, so check ahead for those late-night cravings.
- Parking: The Liberty Square parking structure is your best bet for downtown spots.
How Ann Arbor’s Pizza Scene Changes with the Seasons
One of the unique aspects of Ann Arbor’s pizza scene is its seasonal specialties. Here’s a guide on what to expect throughout the year.
Fall: Game Day Specials
As the leaves turn and the excitement of Michigan football fills the air, Ann Arbor pizzerias roll out special game-day deals. Pizza House’s “Go Blue Special” is a popular choice for watch parties – perfect for sharing and celebrating touchdowns.
Winter: Comfort Pies
When the snow starts to fall, there’s nothing like a warm pizza to keep the winter blues at bay. Bigalora offers a winter truffle and potato pizza that’s as cozy as a blanket. Many pizzerias offer delivery even in snowstorms (and drivers appreciate those extra tips in cold weather).
Spring: Fresh Flavors
With the return of Ann Arbor’s farmers’ markets, pizzerias embrace fresh, local ingredients. Mani Osteria’s spring garlic and ramp pizza is a refreshing change and Anthony’s features spring veggies like asparagus in its pies.
Summer: Festival Slices
During Ann Arbor’s summer festivals, like the Art Fair, many pizzerias offer grab-and-go slices that make for perfect festival food. Wander around with a slice in hand as you explore everything the city has to offer.
Why Ann Arbor’s Pizza Scene is Special – Final Thoughts
Ann Arbor’s pizza scene is about more than just great flavors – it’s part of the town’s culture. From late-night study sessions to special family dinners, Ann Arbor pizzerias have been part of countless memories for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re craving a quick slice, planning a nice dinner out, or hunting for a 2 AM bite, these spots offer something for every pizza lover. And while we’ve highlighted some of the best places here, Ann Arbor has many more hidden gems waiting to be discovered. So grab a friend, go on a pizza adventure, and discover why Ann Arbor’s pizza scene is truly one of a kind!
If you think we missed any must-try pizzerias, feel free to share – we’re always open to new pizza spots and more “research”!
